Haibun – May 28, 2014 – Nationalism

sbandieratori

Once banners were flown and made literally to fly in order to celebrate a family or a quarter of a city, like in Siena, a province or religion.  Then, there were the rich potent reigning families like the Tudors or the Hapsburgs.  Each having their own special family stem symbolising their power and might.  Then one day, the idea of nations became a part of our collective memory.  We suddenly became a “people” no longer just loyal to our family or our province and king but a mythological “people”.

Before that age, conquests were made in the name of a person, not a people.  The “people”, when the last line was drawn were the property of some Vizier, Emporer or King or maybe a religion.

In the 18th century, nationalism was born.  First among nations was England, here’s what Wikipedia has to say on the subject:

With the emergence of a national public sphere and an integrated, country-wide economy in 18th century England, people began to identify with the country at large, rather than the smaller unit of their family, town or province. The early emergence of a popular patriotic nationalism took place in the mid-18th century, and was actively promoted by the government and by the writers and intellectuals of the time. National symbols, anthems, myths, flags and narratives were assiduously constructed and adopted. The Union Flag was adopted as a national one, the patriotic songRule, Britannia! was composed by Thomas Arne in 1740, and the cartoonist John Arbuthnot created the character of John Bull as the personification of the national spirit.

AND

The term nationalism was first used by Johann Gottfried Herder the prophet of this new creed. Herder gave Germans new pride in their origins, and proclaimed a national message within the sphere of language, which he believed determines national thought and culture. He attached exceptional importance to the concept of nationality and of patriotism – “he that has lost his patriotic spirit has lost himself and the whole worlds about himself”, whilst teaching that “in a certain sense every human perfection is national”.

The political development of nationalism and the push for popular sovereignty culminated with the ethnic/national revolutions of Europe, for instance the Greek War of Independence. Since that time, nationalism has become one of the most significant political and social forces in history, perhaps most notably as a major influence or postulate of World War I and especially World War II. Benedict Anderson argued that, “Print language is what invents nationalism, not a particular language per se”.

 

From then onwards we’ve seen the price of rising of nationalism, even today from  the Basque country to Chechnya, the Tuaregs in Mali to the Eritreans … and so many more besides. Nationalism has been used to bond people even more than a religion or a single ruler ever could have done.  Basically, nationalism bonds totally through the creation of the myth of a pre-existing “people”;  united by language, culture, religion and race even when that unity never actually existed, as par example Italy before the Risorgimento, Franco’s Spain or Nazi Germany, just to name a few.

nationalism
a flag, a song, a language
dividing  people


Written for Ligo Haibun – May 26, 2014

 

31 thoughts on “Haibun – May 28, 2014 – Nationalism

  1. You know this is one of the most interesting pieces I have read on the internet. Your haiku is brilliant with it, very clever. I am just fascinated by what you said. Impeccable research an ideas. So very well done.

    Like

    • Thanks Hamish, I’ve lived in many nations of the world and have personally seen the consequences of nationalistic ideas…the only thing hard about writing this haibun was publishing it. Glad you liked it.

      Like

  2. An intelligent and *brave* post indeed!
    I worry about the empty-headed chest-thumping and flag-waving here in my own country. It’s a dangerous situation. People here in the US need to read your post.

    Like

    • Being an American, I do know that this sort post is needed in my home land, especially in recent years. But I’ve had the “opportunity” to see the chest-thumping in other places of the world and it really worries me at times as the consequences are sometimes terrible. Thanks for reading and commenting.

      Like

      • Sorry Georgia — I guess I tend to think of you as a world-wide citizen because of your open-mindedness larger-than-normal worldview. 🙂 So much different than my little corner of “Pennsyltucky”. 😉

        Terrible consequences indeed. Some days I despair.

        Like

        • Not to be sorry…I do have a world-wide citizen view, well, because I’ve lived beyond our borders for well neigh 40 years and some and even when I did live in the States I never stayed more than a couple of years anywhere…so I’m a home-grown wanderer. I think you have a pretty cosmopolitan out-look by the way and rarely think of you as being anything but a world citizen! 🙂

          Like

          • That is a huge compliment! It’s also reassuring. Thank you.

            Some days I feel like I have a giant bull’s eye on my back – walking a fine line – trying to be a voice of reason in the middle of a less-than-reasonable society! Trying to provide an alternate point of view for my son, too — trying to balance out the wing-nut bullcrap he hears at school – without being preachy or telling him what he *ought* to think.

            I’m glad you weren’t offended by my earlier comment. 😀

            Like

          • I know what you mean all along the line. I’ll be honest with you, I felt completely out of place when I was last back in the States…as for trying to teach my children to try to keep open minds…for the most part, it worked, but the problem is that they’re pretty outside the norm in general. I didn’t see anything to be offended by.

            Like

          • I can imagine what you must have felt like – being on the move so much, plus having so much time out of the country. I feel like an outsider and I’ve been here all my life!

            Thankfully my kiddo seems to be learning compassion and anti-group-think fairly well. He’ll approach me and say, “I heard this at school. But I think this instead. What do you think?” I’ll tell him what I think and you can *see* him weighing the opposing view points. I’m so glad he feels that he can come to me for advice and clarification – and generally proud of the conclusions he arrives at. For the most part. 😉

            Like

          • Sounds like you’re doing a great job here, and it’s more mom’s like you that we need to create a new perspective for the future generations…keep up the good work is all I can add! 🙂

            Like

          • Thanks Georgia!

            Sometimes it feels like being a teeny fish swimming against a raging current …. ugh. But in the immortal words of Dory from Finding Nemo, “Just keep swimming … just keep swimming ….”

            Like

          • I can imagine what you must have felt like – being on the move so much, plus having so much time out of the country. I feel like an outsider and I’ve been here all my life!

            Thankfully my kiddo seems to be learning compassion and anti-group-think fairly well. He’ll approach me and say, “I heard this at school. But I think this instead. What do you think?” I’ll tell him what I think and you can *see* him weighing the opposing view points. I’m so glad he feels that he can come to me for advice and clarification – and generally proud of the conclusions he arrives at. For the most part. 😉

            Like

  3. Brilliant – I loved your potted history of nationalism – it was so informative. The concept of nationalism is so ingrained in the consciousness of people now and is the driving force between so many current wars. I wonder if people will ever move beyond it and see we are all one people living on a beautiful planet

    Like

    • One can’t of course cover the all the aspects of nationalism in a post, but I hoped to write enough to at least pose the question of the wisdom in this blind belief … I think we usually don’t think much about it, many don’t realize that they are even influenced by the ideals of nationalism, but as you say, it’s so ingrained in our collective thought. Perhaps we will be able to take another step forward and as we left feudalism will also move on from nationalism…that would be good for all of us…and maybe one day we’ll make that next step as well and realize that we are all one with Gaia.

      Like

      • Beautifully put Georgia. It is all about conscious awareness – speaking and writing about ideas such as these,. even if they are seen as contentious by some, helps raise awareness. Haibun is a wonderful vehicle for this – the form allows for a blend of fact and poetry and saves any political message from becoming too didactic.

        Like

        • Thanks Suzanne, I’m glad you enjoyed the read and I agree the usually one can talk about some of these problems better using a haibun or a story.

          Like

  4. Wow! I love this post, Georgia. The background IS important so we know what it means but your haiku tells us succinctly where it is headed…It is a constant discussion in our province which I try to not listen to, sometimes it is difficult.

    Like

    • I know what you about this sort of difficulty and this sort of talk…it really is very human, that’s how we are made, I mean our animal part…so it’s pretty hard not being territorial…but a we have ambitions of being more than “just” animals…we should try at least to evolve.

      Like

  5. Reblogged this on Cher Shares and commented:
    We hear of “nationalism” with different perspectives…some good, many are tired of hearing about it …this Haibun is quite informative as well the haiku ties it all nicely with…the truth.

    Like

        • So I’ve heard, hopefully people not only in Canada but throughout the world will begin to take a more mature look at living together in harmony.

          Like

          • Yes, well, you may want to translate your text in French for this province…{chuckles} but I suppose just 2 referendums for separation under the belt…may have to go through many more. Just hope I don’t live here when that happens.

            Like

          • We have autonomy problems here in Italy (in fact in the region I live in – The Alto Adige which is a German speaking region that feels more Austrian than Italian) as well…not to speak about people who think they should have the capital in their province…the only solution in the end would be to go onwards and forget about single nations and become a planet…but guess that won’t happen soon!

            Like

in shadows light - walking under weeping pines - spring rain

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.